It is clear, indeed, from the Catholic doctrine of grace, that it is possible for God to move the will so powerfully as to determine not merely that the will shall act, but to determine also that it shall act freely. God is so intimate to the will that He can, so to say, save it from within. However, this is different from His control of the will in the gift of fortitude. In the intellect, a light can be present that is none of our own. However, in the will, how can there be a force that is not itself of the will?
In other words, we must reconcile two contradictory ideas—namely, a will that acts yet does not merit. I am apparently and actually perfectly free, for God does not compel the will unwillingly. Yet, with all my freedom under the guidance of the gift, I cannot acquire merit. That is what we said was the very characteristic of the sevenfold gifts—that they are, in their proper operation, entirely the work of God.